According to ProPublica and KQED, the Santa Paula school district reported counselor David Braff to California's Commission on Teacher Credentialing in 2019 after at least seven students alleged inappropriate touching. The outlets report the agency did not suspend his credentials until his 2024 arrest, and that he worked at three more schools in the meantime. Students, parents and attorneys told the outlets that state investigators did not interview some accusers. Former agency staff said a volunteer review panel at times overlooked evidence. Braff has pleaded not guilty and faces trial on charges involving 15 students; his attorney declined to comment. Commission spokesperson Anita Fitzhugh said no written criteria set discipline levels absent a mandatory conviction and that a comprehensive review of the discipline system is in order. She did not answer questions about specific cases.
Why it matters
The report says the state agency that decides who may work in California's public schools gives its reviewers no guidelines on when to discipline educators. The outlets found two other teachers later convicted of abusing students were also allowed to keep teaching until criminally charged.
These are unproven claims, and everyone named is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Researched with AI assistance from the sources listed here and reviewed under our methodology.
Dont Comply